A
greyhound control steward in Dundalk stadium has resigned following
allegations that he allowed a “ringer” to win a race
last June.
Declan
Haughey left his position at the end of last year after an internal
investigation found irregularities in a race in which Mays Hurryonboy,
a novice, won in a near course-record time of 28.4 seconds, 13
lengths clear of second place.
As
the two-year-old dog’s time was more than two seconds faster
than in a trial three weeks earlier, it raised instant suspicions
among spectators and bookmakers. Greyhound sources said a two-second
improvement in three weeks was almost unprecedented.
The
case is the latest in a series of alleged cheating incidents and
disputes to beset the Irish Greyhound Board (IGB), which will
get almost €12m in state funding this year.
There
is anger in the greyhound community about the findings of the
initial probe into the alleged “ringer”, which was
conducted by Pat Herbert, the board’s head of regulation,
and Jim O’Dwyer, its HR manager. That report rejected the
“ringer” allegations and said that the dog’s
previous slow time was due to an injury. The
investigators were told the dog, which hasn’t raced since,
had been sold to the UK.
The
investigation concluded that a stewards’ inquiry should
have been held on June 15 — the night of the race —
due to the dog’s improvement and because it was presented
at the pre-race weigh-in by an alleged “unauthorised person”.
A
letter from Herbert says the IGB viewed the matter “largely
as an issue of the non-performance” of stewarding in Dundalk
on the night. This outcome was widely deemed unacceptable, and
there were demands for the owners and trainers of Mays Hurryonboy,
as well as those who who may have provided a replacement dog,
to face disciplinary procedures.
The
IGB was forced to reopen its investigation as new details emerged
in November. Jim Martin, chief executive of Dundalk stadium, told
Herbert and Adrian Neilan, chief executive of the IGB, that he
had reviewed a recording of the race with Denis Lee, a colleague,
and was satisfied “as a matter of fact” that the winning
dog “was not Mays Hurryonboy and is 100% a ringer”.
An
unnamed director at Dundalk Stadium wrote: “This is not
personal. This is about upholding the highest possible standards
in greyhound racing ... we are in receipt of millions of euro
of state funding. We have invested this money in our industry
and sport and therefore we need to run our business to the highest
standards of integrity. The mere hint of a ringer is tantamount
to destroying our good name.”
The
IGB said last week that it had referred the incident to its independent
control committee which is chaired by Kevin Heffernan, the former
Dublin football manager. It will meet on January 20.
“Our
investigations have revealed a number of issues which need to
be considered,” said Neilan. “These will be examined
by the control committee prior to any possible further action
being undertaken.”
In
his November email, Martin said he would recommend to his board
that all those involved with Mays Hurryonboy be banned from Dundalk
stadium. These included Tyrone Downey, the trainer of the dog
and a cousin of Declan Haughey, the steward; and Gary Haughey,
the steward’s brother, who presented the dog at weigh-in.
Gary Haughey, a solicitor in Northern Ireland, did not return
calls seeking comment.
It
is understood that all those involved have denied that Mays Hurryonboy
was replaced with another dog.
Mays
Hurryonboy’s registered owner is May Aylward, a greyhound
owner in Waterford. Perry Aylward, her husband, denied that anything
untoward happened in the Dundalk race. “We know of the allegations,”
he said. “We’ve made a statement to the IGB.”
Aylward
said that they still owned Mays Hurryonboy but declined to say
where the dog was or why it had not raced since. He questioned
how feasible it was for Martin to say his blue-coloured dog had
been replaced by a ringer after studying a DVD. “You might
be able to distinguish one greyhound from another, but that’s
it,” he said. “I’ve a lot of greyhounds and
I’ve had to put numbers on them to tell them apart.”
Aylward
warned that it would be “very costly” if Lee and Martin’s
claims were wrong. They won €230 prize money.
Bookmakers
lost money on the unexpected outcome of the race. One who spoke
to The Sunday Times last week said he had paid out €700,
but this was not an unusually large amount.